Quote
Originally Posted by iwire:

However if a piece worker runs across problems, say stripped threads on the box or device are they going to slow down and fix it right or just 'make it look done'.

Rethread with 6-in-1 tap tool: 1 minute
Use sheet metal screw instead: 5 seconds

Wondered where that came from. [Linked Image]

IMHO, our industry uses an interesting blend of the methods. Typically, we price "by drop" or "per opening", especially for new construction. This could be considered a type of piecework, from what I understand.

But then we modify the methodology, and, using a "labor rate" for each task that roughly equals "average" time to complete each task, based on hours of work, we assign a certain number of man-hours to the job as a whole.

If we base our bid on 300 man hours to the build, and only have to pay out for 240, we wind up ahead. Conversly, if we have to pay out 320, we take it in the shorts.

I think we can agree on "different strokes for different folks". Let folks believe their method is best.

Just my $0.02.