Wonder if anybody else has run into this problem? I have a cutler hammer ch panel, when the elevator goes up or down the afi trips(keep in mind this afi has nothing to do with elevator). I talked to cutler hammer and the engineer says that the freq. drive motor is putting noise on the line and when 3 amps are present on the circuit, that noise will trip the circuit (I know this is true because when all lights in sewing room and office are off...no problems)anyway Cutler Hammer says to filter the motor to eliminate the problem. The elevator guy is trying to say he's never had this problem before and of course doesn't want to pay for the filter and labor, his solution is to put in a siemans breaker(yea right). Have any of you guys had problems with residential elevators tripping AFI's? Any thoughts about responsibility for additional $$ cost's appreciated too.
Could you try installing a TVSS on that panel supplying the AFCI branch circuit? It's possible that some TVSS's may offer basic noise filtering capabilities. They arenít too expensive and if it works, you could both invoice it as an extra and come out smelling like a rose.
Re: Elevator tripping AFI
#193801 04/20/1012:36 PM04/20/1012:36 PM
The TVSS clamps spikes at 300v or so (for a 120/240 service). I can't see that helping and if something does help it would be on that circuit, not the whole panel. There may be some kind of noise suppression that would work but I would think it would need to be be right at the motor or VFD/starter. I have always been skeptical about engineers saying "noise". I know it can happen but that is also a catch all for "I don't have a clue". Do you have access to a scope and a current probe?. I would still start by swapping in a GFCI as a test. If that trips I would be looking for an intermittent ground fault.
If I understand the way the snake renders it's oil in an AFCI they are looking for current spikes, not voltage spikes, that is why I would start with a scope and a current probe.
Triplen harmonics are not really noise, they are very regular beat frequency waves within the base wave that get superimposed on it.
You can certainly start easter egging around throwing anti-noise hardware at the problem but at a certain point you may need to take a look at what is really happening. If this is not one of the new breakers that has indicators of whether they tripped on an arc or a ground fault, I would eliminate the possibility of this being a ground fault problem first.
The FC filters provide filtering for frequency inverters and variable speed motor drives. Designed for very noisy applications, they attenuate conducted interference at low and high frequency ranges and protect programmable logic controllers from RF noise on the AC power line. These filters perform best when installed on the line side of the motor drive. The FC filters better prevent noise from returning to the line, enabling equipment to meet strict European regulations on RFI. Suited for field wiring applications, these filters are ideal for EMC troubleshooting and field refurbishing. The FC filters feature side flanges for easy mounting and DIN type terminals which eliminate live metal parts, allowing safer and easier connection. The filters could also be sold as an accessory to motor drives marketed into Europe.