Another way of looking at it is that it is supposed to put all bidders on a level playing field. The pros and cons are viewed differently depending on how your effected by the law. If you're an electrician residing and working in/or around Manhattan, paying the local taxes and cost of living, then you would be for the prevailing wage rule. If you were an out-of-state electrician and unemployed, you certainly would benefit from the increased wage via prevailing wage to cover your travel and possible lodging expenses. If you're a local taxpayer, you may not like it at face value but the wages earned by local electricians, who are also local taxpayers, will stay in the local economy.

If you're a bottom-feeding entrepreneur, general contractor or developer, then you would seek the cheapest labor in all the land. Of course, you would have your government contract taken away, due to gross incompetence, given to a higher paying competent contractor and cost the taxpayers even more in the end. [Linked Image]

I agree, it is not a union vs. non-union issue, though the union scales are readily available numbers to work with. On most of the large privately funded worksites in my area I don't usually recongnize the electrical contractor because they are from some distant place where the cost of living is significantly less expensive and his workforce is payed per their "home-town" scale, even though they often get stuck with a lot of traveling expenses. The developer and the coffee truck guy are the only ones doing well here.

Andy