Scott, a drawing would be great if not too much trouble, I'm usually pretty good with control wiring but for some reason this problem is confusing me.
Greg, I need the pump to shut off at high water, I guess high water is not really the right terminology as it's not a high water condition it's where my water level needs to be.
Kjay, I have never seen an electrode system, I bet thats what was here at one time but they are using the electrodes to carry line voltage now.