Alright - despite my earlier post [Linked Image] - I don't think I'd feel right without one of the following, whether "required" by Code or not:

1) A single disconnecting means for the entire building

OR

2) A single disconnect for each of the occupancies, whether on the meters or at each individual panel

OR (preferably, although more expensive)

3)Both of the above.

Where we are reaching a sticking point is the definition of "service" - whether Code intends to address the structure (yes) or the individual dwelling occupancy (the single apartments)(yes).

If I were the AHJ, I think that the lack of at least #2 above (a main on each panel for each unit) would be grounds for a "recommendation" to bring it into compliance. If it was for a =>50% remodel, I'd insist on it.

Glad it's getting reworked, no matter how "legal" it is.

Nods to E57 for 230.71(A)