ECN Forum
Posted By: Admin Saving Customer Money - 12/15/04 11:20 PM
Quote
Hello, I thought these photos would make for a nice discussion. A local contractor (carpenter) likes to do his own wiring to save the homeowners money. This is a sample of his work. What do you think?

- ElectricEagle
[Linked Image]

[Linked Image]

[Linked Image]

[Linked Image]
Posted By: jdadamo Re: Saving Customer Money - 12/16/04 12:44 AM
Ewwww that's solid aluminum wire... it has to be 10 or 12 gauge. Where did he even get that wire? Couldn't have been new...

Not to mention the other problems. Looks like 3-wire service was brought to a subpanel instead of 4 wire. Ground wire being used as a neutral. Undersized horribly. etc etc No disconnect.

[This message has been edited by jdadamo (edited 12-15-2004).]
Posted By: Electric Eagle Re: Saving Customer Money - 12/16/04 03:12 AM
Actually there's no solid AL, but still major problems. Some things you can't tell from the picks are the "service cable" is 6-2 w/ #10 ground. All breakers are overfused. 14 gauge on 20 amps and 10 gauge on 40 amps. The sub panel main is 100 amp. All neutrals and grounds combined in the sub. For some reason he put noalox on the CU wires.

Not pictured are numerous other violations. No GFI's in the wet bar. No crimps or wire nuts on grounds at any device. Wire nuts not tight and wires not pretwisted.

This job was a fire waitng to happen. My crew took everything appart and corrected everything they could find. 2 guys were there 6 hours making the corrections.

The bad news is this guy has many more projects in the area. We are scheduled to go to another house next week that he worked on. All I know now is the guy's first name, when I find the last name I'm going to tell him to stop wiring or be turned in, I may just turn him in.

[This message has been edited by Electric Eagle (edited 12-15-2004).]
Posted By: electure Re: Saving Customer Money - 12/16/04 04:06 AM
Must be a carpenter...Look, he didn't want to deface that beautiful framing with romex staples.
Posted By: e57 Re: Saving Customer Money - 12/16/04 05:27 AM
If this gent has a license (As a Carpenter) he should loose that too, along with some jail time, cause that is just criminal.
Posted By: cheman6 Re: Saving Customer Money - 12/17/04 04:07 AM
oh how many times I have seen this, give the customer a price find someone who can do it cheaper (aka your buddy the carpenter of uncle joe) and then viola your back doing a massive repair, service call. Just because somebody wanted to save a dollar, realy worth it right.
Posted By: Big Jim Re: Saving Customer Money - 12/17/04 09:44 AM
Wasn't there a commercial a while back for oil filters that said. "Pay me now or pay me later."?
At least, you probably won't be electricuted if your filter fails.
Posted By: slumlordworker Re: Saving Customer Money - 12/22/04 03:03 PM
what a hack it is clear that this person has no knowledge of electrical wiring practics. or just doesnot care. he should be turned in and beat down for this.

is the second pic panel over loaded looks like more than 40 breakers in that pabel. what about each wire having a connector where it enters the panel.

what about only one circuit per knockout
is there 2 wires under the main lug in the second picture

wow i would to have gotten this job seems like fun
Posted By: SvenNYC Re: Saving Customer Money - 12/23/04 03:02 PM
Save the customer money?

Considering the home-owner has to hire an electrician to CLEAN UP the carpenter's mess, how is that saving someone money?

I'm not an electrician, but even I could wire a panel in a much neater way than this clown!!

Some people should just stick with hammering wood together and leave the playing-with-wires to those who know what they're doing. [Linked Image]

Also, in one of those pictures, it looks like he used those half-sized circuit breakers. I thought those things aren't supposed to be used anymore.

[This message has been edited by SvenNYC (edited 12-23-2004).]
Posted By: Electric Eagle Re: Saving Customer Money - 12/24/04 05:54 PM
Quote
Also, in one of those pictures, it looks like he used those half-sized circuit breakers. I thought those things aren't supposed to be used anymore.

Actually, that is the original panel and they are GE slim line breakers. While not my personal choice, they are perfectly legal. However, this hack did put a Sq D Homeline breaker in that GE panel which I don't believe is classified to be there.
Posted By: Lostazhell Re: Saving Customer Money - 01/03/05 12:07 AM
As scary as the thing here show... People seem to think that getting a bargain on electrical work equates to, oh say,.... finding someone to change your oil for $9.95.... They see someone like one of us change an outlet in 60 seconds & say to themselves... "Hey! Anyone can do this stuff... " When in reality, the people here do the things they need to do as second nature.. They know their limits & know when they need to ask questions.... This is what makes a good electrician.. Not to say all handymen, but the ones I've cleaned up after myself have done some BRAZEN things... (a few have had their work grace the pages of ECN) Understanding there's wayyy more to things than just making the light bulb turn on is what separates us... they can make the light bulb glow... but can they do it safely?.... We cost more because we do it right...

In the long run, now the H.O. has paid the handy man... Now he's paid me to make it right, & THEN paid me to fix the existing that he screwed up mickey mousing the new stuff in! .... I'd call it job security [Linked Image]

-Randy
© ECN Electrical Forums