ECN Forum
Posted By: EVAD7 SHOWER SHOCKER - 12/26/03 01:41 PM
I got a service call last week. It has turned into a mystery. The homeowner is getting shocks from the shower. Ceramic floor, basement bathroom, plastic floor drain, and 3- 8 volts reading. I took the service ground to the street side of the water meter. The voltage won't go away.
Posted By: PCBelarge Re: SHOWER SHOCKER - 12/26/03 02:03 PM
If available, try bonding the cold/warm water pipes feeding the shower. Check also to see if there are some 'bootstrapping' issues that is causing objectionable current to flow.

Pierre
Posted By: Electric Eagle Re: SHOWER SHOCKER - 12/26/03 02:07 PM
I had a situation a few months ago that I posted aboutsimilar to this. In my situation the customer got shocked whenever they touched the outside spigot with bare feet on the ground. It turned out the power company was "leaking" current into the ground from the Xfmr. All power in this area is underground, is your area on poles or underground?
Posted By: George Corron Re: SHOWER SHOCKER - 12/26/03 02:12 PM
Exact same scenario, had this happen, may be of some help to you.

POCO had loose (barely functional) neutral splice at pole, pole grounded properly - meaning a ground wire down to the earth.

Service grounded properly with a ground rod and water pipe ground.

Neutral path had such high resistance, the over current had established a path through the earth for a percentage of current.

POCO non-responsive, saying "It's still there" and would not remake splice, even though it was quite evident it was rusty, nasty, loose.

Climbed pole myself, cleaned and crimped new splice, problem solved.

IOW, check your neutral connections ALL the way back, I'm willing to be it is what you will find. If he has close neighbors, you can also be having a problem from one of them.

I'm reminded here of one Creighton wrote up where a solenoid from a neighbors washing machine was causing significant problems in the house because they were both tied to the water line, in my case the house was very rural so neighbors did not fit into the picture.

Let us know, this sounds interesting.
Posted By: harold endean Re: SHOWER SHOCKER - 12/26/03 04:00 PM
Ditto here, the POCO had a bad neutral. We also have a pool with the same problem. However I haven't heard the outcome of this one yet.
Posted By: earlydean Re: SHOWER SHOCKER - 12/26/03 05:37 PM
To solve the immediate problem: getting zapped in the shower, just bond both hot, cold, and the drain at the shower together. Assumedly all are metal, else how could the person in the shower be completing the circuit?
Posted By: earlydean Re: SHOWER SHOCKER - 12/26/03 05:39 PM
oops, re-read the origional posting: plastic drain. Must be getting zapped through the ceramic floor via concrete underneath. Is this shower on the bottom floor? In the dirt?
Posted By: golf junkie Re: SHOWER SHOCKER - 12/26/03 07:59 PM
Had this exact same problem a while back. It was improper ground on the electric water heater.

Good luck.

GJ
Posted By: maintenanceguy Re: SHOWER SHOCKER - 12/27/03 03:42 AM
A neighbor had same problem about 10 years ago. Nobody could figure out why. Everything grounded properly, in fact, everything was grunded to everything else at multiple locations in an attempt to solve problem.

Turned out to be corroded ground rods at the POCO's substaion 1/4 mile from the house. Rural area, no other houses nearby to be affected.
Posted By: Anonymous Re: SHOWER SHOCKER - 12/27/03 04:21 AM
Is the water heater gas or electric? I had a very interesting one where a subpanel was fed with 3 wires using the conduit for the equipment ground. Someone added circuits and landed the neutrals on the equipment grounding bus, thus sending neutral current through the conduit. Well the conduit eventually failed as a conductor and the neutral current found it's way back thru the furnace grounding conductor, which was on that same bus.The neutral current from the other loads in the panel was travelling on the furnace grounding conductor back to the furnace, where it then travelled along the gas line to the water heater, where it travelled to the water lines and out to the main. Whenever someone would take a shower, they became part of this return circuit.
The gas pipe in the kitchen actually got so hot it blackened the ceiling where it passed thru to the attic, probably touching against the metal lath.
Rewiring the panel and providing a 4 wire feed fixed everything, although at first it was not obvious to me why the pipes were hot and I thought there might be another problem. I knew the panel was wrong and fixed it right away, but it took me a lot of forehead wrinkling thinking in the days after to figure out exactly what was happening and why.
Brian
Posted By: EVAD7 Re: SHOWER SHOCKER - 12/27/03 04:06 PM
Thanks for the ideas. The service is overhead. A recent street reconsruction project was done in the area.( maybe this is
related). I'm waiting for the POCO to check the service in the area.
Posted By: pforte Re: SHOWER SHOCKER - 12/29/03 05:37 AM
I agree with all of the above opinions but want to add something from my own experience. I had a customer who was getting a shock from in the tub when water was running. It was a combination of a bad neutral connection from the utility and someone at some point ran a wire from a circuit that lost a nuetral to the nearest water pipe.
What happens in that instance is the current from the circuit is using the pipe as a nuetral. If you put your body between the pipe and running water and the water happens to provide a better path to ground....well you know the scenario. That was the problem in that case. Check all neutral and ground connections.
Posted By: phosgene Re: SHOWER SHOCKER - 01/03/04 11:28 PM
Heating element in water heater may be bad, insulating material may be broken.
© ECN Electrical Forums