ECN Forum
Posted By: rowdyrudy Another Shortcutter - 09/12/03 03:05 PM
Friend in a nearby area asked me to look at an installation he had an EC perform for a time clock on a well pump. The pump was 240V and the clock had a 120V motor. 12/2 w/g was routed to the clock and the ground was connected as a neutral to the clock.
Friend contacted county inspector and police. No permit/no inspection. EC out on $250.00 bond. Hearing in two weeks. This kind of workmanship hurts the legit EC.
Rowdy
Posted By: George Re: Another Shortcutter - 09/12/03 10:21 PM
I always run 3+G for 240 circuits just as a protection in such cases.

Before you lay blame ...

A good lawyer might compare this instalation to the allowable installation of a 240v appliance to existing 2+G and continuing to use the ground as a neutral.

A good lawyer might suggest that requiring a permit for installing a clock is a bit much.
Posted By: Electric Eagle Re: Another Shortcutter - 09/13/03 12:48 AM
Was someone hurt?

Yes, it was a bad installation, but arresting the guy was a bit much wasn't it? I don't think the police would arrest an electrician for something like this in my area, but you might have to go before the electrical contractors board and risk losing your license, but a warning would be most likely.

Why didn't your friend get you to do the job in the first place and what made him want to have you look at it?

[This message has been edited by Electric Eagle (edited 09-12-2003).]
Posted By: ga.sparky56 Re: Another Shortcutter - 09/13/03 04:20 AM
I'd agree with Eagle.

I've been asked to do similar installations.Lights and/or receps in the pumphouse off the pump ckt come to mind.

Usually the people that ask for this are too cheap and scream in pain when you price the correct installation,so they find a "handyman" or someone who's "done some wiring" to do it anyway.

It's a bad installation,and the line must be drawn somewhere but that would be mild compared to some things you find around here.

Arresting the guy sounds a bit overboard to me.
Posted By: Pinemarten Re: Another Shortcutter - 09/13/03 09:39 AM
Wouldn't it have been easier to put in a small (50VA) 240/120 transformer and then fuse the secondary L1(X1)and ground the neutral (X2)?
I've done it right up to 600/120. As far as I know, it is legal here. (Canada)
Posted By: electure Re: Another Shortcutter - 09/13/03 10:22 AM
How's about just buying a t/c with a 208-277 volt motor in the first place?
They're readily available...S
Posted By: PCBelarge Re: Another Shortcutter - 09/13/03 05:29 PM
George
You mention running a threewire + ground. How do you get a 120v circuit if you are using the two ungrounded conductors for 240v? I am guessing that the White conductor is to be used for the grounded conductor.

Pierre
Posted By: classicsat Re: Another Shortcutter - 09/14/03 03:10 AM
There are three insulated conductors, rew, black for hots, the white for neutral.
Posted By: rowdyrudy Re: Another Shortcutter - 09/14/03 03:36 PM
He just picked the wrong guy to screw. Jay's uncle is a judge and his brother is an attorney. No, Jay didn't go for the cheap and I retired 10 years ago. It wasn't just a time clock but pressure pump and other items associated. The installation was pathetic in its entirety.
Rowdy
Posted By: nesparky Re: Another Shortcutter - 09/16/03 02:27 AM
I hope that that will rub off on the DA here. The only way to get rid of fly by nite work is to make the jerks pay more for the bad work than it would have cost for the work to be done correctly. A stint in jail and a heavy fine is a start.
© ECN Electrical Forums