ECN Forum
Posted By: ahickey Removing BX marks from wall - 09/18/09 06:16 AM
Does anyone have any tricks/tips for removing the dark marks that BX cable leaves on a painted wall? I've tried the Magic Eraser in the past, but that usually messes up the paint finish. frown
Posted By: Lostazhell Re: Removing BX marks from wall - 09/18/09 06:25 PM
I've used the Dottie hand wipes with moderate success in the past. Thinking about what's actually on the BX, (which is an oil) I might also try a bit of dish soap on a damp sponge.

whatever you try, test it out in an inconspicuous location on the wall first..

good luck =)
Posted By: electure Re: Removing BX marks from wall - 09/19/09 12:02 AM

I, like Lostazhell iagree , have used dish soap or liquid hand soap with wet paper towels to get that stuff off. Be sure to rinse the wall when you're done to get rid of the soap, and dry it off. (it takes a lot of paper towels)
Posted By: Alan Belson Re: Removing BX marks from wall - 09/19/09 09:40 AM
Why do the makers put the oil on it to start with?
Posted By: JoeTestingEngr Re: Removing BX marks from wall - 09/19/09 03:08 PM
I'm not saying that this works BUT I'm amazed at all the things that WD-40 takes off. I just showed someone how well it works on what's left after you remove a price sticker. It would be interesting to see how it works with BX coating on a painted surface. I do remember ruining a silver embroidered skydiving windbreaker by carrying a roll of BX. That was an expensive lesson.
Joe
Posted By: mbhydro Re: Removing BX marks from wall - 09/19/09 03:31 PM
I wonder if its oiled to keep it from rusting while its in storage, sort of like sheet metal for heating ducts have a coating on it when you buy it at the store.
Posted By: Tom Re: Removing BX marks from wall - 09/19/09 04:32 PM
I think the oil is most likely used to lubricate the dies that form the armor. Aluminum jacketed MC can be worse as it seems to contain graphite.

I think the best thing to do is avoid the problem in the first place by leaving a roll of the cable out in the weather for a month or so & let mother nature wash it off for you.
Posted By: renosteinke Re: Removing BX marks from wall - 09/19/09 05:44 PM
Well, Tom, I'll give you half credit. laugh

Nearly all AC, MC, FMC used today has an outer jacket made fron aluminum. I agree that the oil is there as part of the manufacturering process.

Aluminum does, in fact, react with air. This results in a layer of aluminum oxide (think 'aluminum rust' so to speak)forming on the surface of the aluminum. While this layer doesn't flake of as real rust flakes off of iron, it does come off fairly easily. The acids in your sweat combine with aluminum, which is why your hands get so black when you work with MC.

Now .... think for a moment .... what do you get when you mix fine colored particles witha light oil? We have a special word for this mix. We call it 'paint.'

So, in handling the MC we make what amounts to a black paint- which then rubs off onto the wall. Remove the oil, and the black stuff - aluminum oxide- remains.

Unless the surface is completely smooth and non-porous, you're stuck with having to cover your marks with more paint- paint that matches the wall this time.
Posted By: Niko Re: Removing BX marks from wall - 09/20/09 11:11 PM
I have been using simple green with great success for most of my cleaning for me it works great. i use wd-40 to remove tar.

Edward
Posted By: KJay Re: Removing BX marks from wall - 09/22/09 03:54 AM
I always carry a spray bottle of ZEP glass cleaner mix and a roll of white paper towels. I mix the ZEP myself from concentrate and like to make it a little strong, so it will remove oils like that MC gook and oxide, but not so strong that it takes latex paint off walls.
I use it for cleaning just about everything. Every light fixture and wall plate gets cleaned after installation when I do the finish on a new house.
Watch out for those paper towels with the color prints on them though. That print color stuff [Soy ink??] comes of on the walls and leaves a nasty stain that is extremely difficult to remove.
Posted By: ahickey Re: Removing BX marks from wall - 09/22/09 06:08 AM
Thanks for the replies! We didn't address the marks when we went back to do the panel change, but I'll try out both the ZEP and the Simple Green in future.

Magic Eraser got the marks off the last time I tried it, but it also took the surface luster off the paint; you could tell where I'd used it. (The Magic Eraser works like a charm for getting BX/box oil fingerprints off T-bar ceiling tiles, though!)
Posted By: Tesla Re: Removing BX marks from wall - 09/23/09 10:16 PM
Pardon my ignorance, but just how is it that you're getting BX oils all over the finished surfaces?

Posted By: Alan Belson Re: Removing BX marks from wall - 09/24/09 09:19 PM
I agree with Reno, the marks are probably aluminum oxide or galvanising zinc-metal marks rather than actual 'oil', which would wipe off easily with dish-soap, if it were visible anyway. The makers will use some kind of die lube when forming the sheath, but it's more likely to be stearate powder or talc. The answer of course is to not mark the wall in the first place, by feeding the stuff out of a polythene bag or sleeve. Work smart, not hard. You are not getting paid for chores like cleaning up avoidable marks, which = less profit & less time with your feet up twirling a martini as the sun sets.
Posted By: McClarysElectric Re: Removing BX marks from wall - 10/05/09 03:21 AM
The ideal wipes work really well.
© ECN Electrical Forums