ECN Forum
Posted By: petey_c Lights dimming? - 02/04/08 08:35 PM
Here's a question that's probably already been asked. Occasionally when I'm working residential, a customer will ask, "Why do the lights dim momentarily when my A/C (or other heavy load device) turns on. I try and give a non-technical or tech-light explanation. It's usually the "electricity is like water in a plumbing line. You're taking a shower and someone flushes the toilet. You experience a momentary loss of "pressure."" Any thoughts? pete
Posted By: sparkyinak Re: Lights dimming? - 02/05/08 12:31 AM
It can be several things. It is all dependent on the problem.

* Too many things on the circuit and it is trying to trip the breaker but the surge is over before it can. in layman's term: It is like trying to stick 10 pounds of crap in a 5 pound box.

* The service capacity is too much at the transformer and can not carry the load. In layman's term: It is like the little engine that coundn't.

*They have a serious problem with their service neutral. There is potential fire or electrical damage to equipment due to higher the normal voltage. In layman's term:
it is like there is potential fire or electrical damage to equipment due to higher the normal voltage.
Posted By: JoeTestingEngr Re: Lights dimming? - 02/05/08 01:55 AM
Just explain to them how a motor takes much more current to start and get up to speed than to run at that speed. Have them think about how little fuel is required to hold 60MPH on the highway. It will be intuitive to them that it takes more when they go from zero to sixty. Then have them consider what it would take from under their hood if their car could even come close to zero to sixty in under three seconds. Then just explain that the huge current draw causes a voltage drop that causes the lights to dim even though they draw little current.
Joe
Posted By: SteveFehr Re: Lights dimming? - 02/05/08 11:45 AM
Just tell them the truth- the power company are a bunch of cheapasses and undersize the aerial drop from the powerline transformer to their house, and then when big motors like a heat pump start up, they draw more power than the rest of the house combined for a fraction of a second. So when the big motor on heat pump starts up, the in-rush of current drops the voltage on the line into the house a few volts. It takes surprisingly little voltage drop to make a notible dimming of lights.

You can even point out that a typical 5hp motor has inrush of 168A, even if it only draws 20A while it's running. Shoot, if the pole pig is only 25kVA, that in-rush would completely saturate the transformer and dim *everyone's* lights.
Posted By: petey_c Re: Lights dimming? - 02/05/08 12:01 PM
Steve, Yeah, the PoCos are cheapasses... I've seen people's eyes start to glaze over when I start anything remotely technical (tech-lite). They seem to relate better to the sudden inrush of hot/cold water whilst they're taking a shower, than current. Had the pleasure of spending several months as a guest of the Navy out in Chesapeake at the Residence Inn off of Greenbriar. Nice area, considered getting my Va/NC license ('cause I was bored), but couldn't get the paperwork sent to me. Wife wouldn't be able to find it. Thanks for all the replies
Posted By: harold endean Re: Lights dimming? - 02/10/08 03:06 AM
Another thought, Ask the homeowner (HO) if the dimming lights are in just one room or in the whole house. Sometimes the problem is in the branch circuit. If the lights dim in the whole house the problem could be in the main service panel, the meter, the connections at the head or out on the street. It might take some time and patience to figure out just where the problem is located.
Posted By: Rewired Re: Lights dimming? - 02/10/08 04:17 PM
If they are having a problem with the lights flickering when an A/C starts, assuming there is no actual problem with the wiring or the service etc, you might want to try putting a " kick start" hard starting device in the A/C unit. I did on my parent's A/C (for other reasons) and now there is little or no flicker in their lights.

A.D
Posted By: wire_twister Re: Lights dimming? - 02/12/08 02:27 AM
Do you have a link for the "Kick start" device, I might want one for my house. 15kva pole pig + 5 ton heat pump = dim lights for split second.
Posted By: SteveFehr Re: Lights dimming? - 02/12/08 11:42 AM
http://www.kickstartoem.com/

It's a capacitor and a relay wired in parallel with the motor. Don't most condensors come with one of these already built into it?
Posted By: LarryC Re: Lights dimming? - 02/12/08 02:05 PM
They are also known as hard start kits. Talk to your AC&R technician to verify that there is not another reason for the large current draw when starting.

Larry C
Posted By: wire_twister Re: Lights dimming? - 02/12/08 08:28 PM
Unit is only 5 years old and has made the lights flicker from the first start up. 15 kva pole pig and 2/0 alum underground wire on utility side of meter, our local emc likes to put em in cheap, secondary run is about 135 feet from transformer to meter
Posted By: Rewired Re: Lights dimming? - 02/12/08 10:42 PM
Steve: Most condensors I have seen do not have one of these built in, but I will say as well as reducing the lighting "flicker" when my parents compressor starts, the kick-start will actually start the compressor with full head pressure, such as right after a momentary power interruption.
I really am surprised all referigeration compressors don't have one of these right from the factory!

A.D
Posted By: wire_twister Re: Lights dimming? - 02/12/08 11:23 PM
Kick Starts web site claims that all units used to have them, but that the manufacturers discontinued the use to save costs. Another case of cheap not always being good.
© ECN Electrical Forums