I'd be fine with a field constructed cover provided it was done in a neat manner. The cover and 'reuse' of the box might not meet the code in that it wouldn't be the OEM cover or it's intended use but IMO it would meet the intent. The wires would be protected. Really what's the diffenence between using this box and buying something new. What would be the improvement?
I'm assuming this person would clean up the mess, add some support for the bird's nest entering the box, and perhaps label some stuff.
If it was mine I'd clean it up and put a nice new cover on it with labels, etc. It's not nice and new but it's still functional.
Bring it on....
[This message has been edited by RSmike (edited 07-01-2005).]
Re: Open cabinet with exposed wires#105719 07/01/0503:01 PM07/01/0503:01 PM
I wouldn't have a problem with a fabricated steel cover having adequate corrosion protection.
I might have a problem with the way the box is supported. There are some cables running behind it, so maybe it's not flat against or mounted to the wall (or whatever that is).
I'd want that top-center KO closed out.
And I'd take a real close look at one of the cables at the bottom, second out from the big EMT. There's something weird about it, almost like a short piece of new armor was spliced on for a little more length.
Then I'd wonder how a romex and BX are getting in through the same twin connector at the top right.
After all of which, the EC and I would have a chat about cable support.
But the cover? Ok with me.
Re: Open cabinet with exposed wires#105720 07/01/0503:38 PM07/01/0503:38 PM
Would it be better to use a "super" neutral wire of sufficient gauge than all the separate neutrals? You'd need a terminal bar insulated from the box to land all the neutrals to connect to the superneutral. But if there are circuits from both sides of the 110/220 line in there (likely if it was a panel) currents from one side would get shared at the bar in this box instead of having to travel to the new circuit breaker panel serving this box on one neutral and back again on another neutral wire. Less heat and wire in the big conduit that I presume is feeding to the main panel.
Re: Open cabinet with exposed wires#105721 07/01/0511:14 PM07/01/0511:14 PM
I avoid "super neutral" wires- for the simple reason that you are creating a place where a loose wire would result in the connected circuits receiving 220 volts. Sure, the code allows it, but I prefer to "join" neutrals only at the panel.
Re: Open cabinet with exposed wires#105722 07/03/0511:22 AM07/03/0511:22 AM
II. Construction Specifications 312.10 Material. Cabinets, cutout boxes, and meter socket enclosures shall comply with 312.10(A) through (C).
(A) Metal Cabinets and Cutout Boxes. Metal enclosures within the scope of this article shall be protected both inside and outside against corrosion. FPN:For information on protection against corrosion, see 300.6.
(B) Strength. The design and construction of enclosures within the scope of this article shall be such as to secure ample strength and rigidity. If constructed of sheet steel, the metal thickness shall not be less than 1.35 mm (0.053 in.) uncoated.
Bob Badger Construction & Maintenance Electrician Massachusetts
Re: Open cabinet with exposed wires#105724 07/03/0509:14 PM07/03/0509:14 PM
What would a "Listed Enclosure" provide that this does not. More money for someone sure but what else. If I never hear listing violation again it will be too soon. Seems to be the hot catchphrase these days.
Re: Open cabinet with exposed wires#105726 07/04/0509:55 AM07/04/0509:55 AM