ECN Forum
Posted By: mxslick Arc flash accident video - 06/03/07 08:18 PM
Found another video, this one drives home the dangers of arc flash incidents.


LINK HERE

WARNING: Some of the images in this video are VERY graphic!!

Pictures from the accident site appear at around 55 seconds.

Posted By: Roger Re: Arc flash accident video - 06/03/07 10:15 PM
Thank you for the link Tony, it certainly brings home then reality of the dangers associated with our trade.

BTW, FWIW, I spent 10 days of whirl pool therapy on my hands from a 480 volt blast, but that does not compare with Donnie's accident.

Roger
Posted By: mxslick Re: Arc flash accident video - 06/04/07 03:24 AM
You're welcome, Roger.

Over the last 20 years I have been very fortunate and have had a few close calls, not only while working as an electrician but in my cinema service trade and doing work on my own property as well. I have taken some risks that I now look back on and realize how stupid (and lucky) I was.

Not everyone (including me at times) realizes just how dangerous electricity can be. So I hope that we all take a moment to think before we act, and to enforce shutdown, lockout and tagout no matter how inconvenient it may be.

Sorry to hear of your incident as well. Would you mind sharing how it happened?

Posted By: Roger Re: Arc flash accident video - 06/04/07 09:52 AM
Tony, I'll post back later today.

Roger
Posted By: Roger Re: Arc flash accident video - 06/04/07 10:54 PM
Tony, we were adding hardware to a 1600 amp Federal Pacific switchboard for a hospital renovation, I had just finished installing a 400 amp breaker and removed my gloves to take a break before tackling the next 250 amp breaker.

I was going to remove the hardware for (2) one-hundred amp breaker spaces to make room for the 250 amp hardware, so with out my gloves on I stuck a screw driver in the A phase 100 amp buss to see how I might have to guard the surrounding metal before I gloved back up. (extremely stupid move on my part)

Well, I found out that this buss was about to fall anyways and all it needed was my screw driver barely touching it. It fell into the B phase. I was lucky that the blast went at 90 degrees to my right instead of directly back at me. I ended up with mostly second (and some small third degree) burns and couldn't see anything but blurs for three days.

The next morning I was back at the hospital (not the same one) having the skin trimmed from my hands by a doctor with a pair of scissors.

I was lucky in that I did heal and have no permanent injuries.

Roger
Posted By: HotLine1 Re: Arc flash accident video - 06/07/07 12:17 AM
Roger:
Just stumbled by this forum & thread. Never stopped by here before in 5 years! Sorry to hear about your incident; glad all is well.

I have a few arc flash videos that I show my students at Vo-Tech. Bussman and one I recently got from Sq D. I'm heading over to the above link now.

John
Posted By: HotLine1 Re: Arc flash accident video - 06/07/07 12:25 AM
Touching video. The Bussman uses a manequin to show forces, and some good slow mo shots.
Hopefully, it gets the entry level guys to see what could happen!

John
Posted By: Roger Re: Arc flash accident video - 06/07/07 01:43 AM
Thank you John. That was back in 95.

Roger
Posted By: mxslick Re: Arc flash accident video - 06/07/07 05:02 AM
Roger: Thank you for sharing the details, and I am glad to hear things turned out o.k. But why wasn't I surprised that it was Federal Pacific switchgear? Some of their commercial stuff seems almost as bad as the FPE resi stuff.

John: Thanks for your comments as well. I agree, I posted this to show everyone what could happen. Sadly, it doesn't take a lot of effort to find a lot of other examples of close calls (or worse.)

Quote
Never stopped by here before in 5 years!


That is something that concerns me. I am as guilty as anyone else, but if you look at the number of views on pretty much any of the safety threads, and compare that with any of the other topical threads, there is a big disparity. Guess safety discussions aren't as "popular" as some of our other topics.

I'm not intending that comment to act as if I'm any better than anyone else, but I do call 'em as I see 'em. And plead guilty of that same offense. smile

Thanks to both of you for your replies.





Posted By: HotLine1 Re: Arc flash accident video - 06/08/07 11:58 AM
MX:
In addition to this forum section, I'm not a frequent visitor to a few others. As to having concerns for the safety of those in or thinking about entering our trade.

That said, in both of my 12 week courses at Vo-Tech, I show videos regarding how accidents happen, and the results of same. Some of the video content, as the link you posted is graphic, but...it gets the point accross.

My reason for not visiting each section on this forum is probably like a lot of other guys here, lack of time, not lack of interest.

Harried lives, lack of time....welcome to America.

Take care, stay safe

John
Posted By: HotLine1 Re: Arc flash accident video - 06/09/07 01:05 AM
Retired Helper:
OK, then send it to me in a PM, or e-mail, about now I could use a good laugh.

Not so coincidental, but around 8:45AM today I got a call re Fire Dept at scene of electrical explosion. Got to site, the electrician was already airlifted to Burn Ctr, and the building was 'dark'.

Found out it was a 100 amp disco (fused) rack in a GE Spectra swbd. 3K amp main in adjacent elec room; 1600 amp feeder to this swbd; all 480v. Yeah, right at eye level for most guys. Damaged rack was removed, & power restored to bldg. (Reset GF on main that had tripped)

Condition of electrician at this time (8:50PM) is unknown.

BTW, for those of you that don't know me..I'm the AHJ in that Twp.

John
Posted By: mxslick Re: Arc flash accident video - 06/09/07 06:27 AM
Retired Helper:

Yeah, PM that story to me also, please. smile

John:

Any idea on the cause of that incident? Any pictures of the damaged gear you can share?
Posted By: mxslick Re: Arc flash accident video - 06/09/07 06:30 AM
Originally Posted by HotLine1
<snip>

Harried lives, lack of time....welcome to America.

Take care, stay safe

John


How true!!! smile
Posted By: HotLine1 Re: Arc flash accident video - 06/09/07 01:19 PM
MX:
Bldg is 'ultra secure'; entry controlled; NO cameras, etc. I'll see if the damaged 'rack' is taken to another area Mon/Tues.
I'm reserving my opinions here until I determine more facts. 'Whatever' will be posted here.
Pure opinion on my part as of now is a phase to ground fault at the disco, what was "hot" is unknown.
John
Posted By: LK Re: Arc flash accident video - 06/10/07 02:00 AM
Originally Posted by HotLine1
MX:
Bldg is 'ultra secure'; entry controlled; NO cameras, etc. I'll see if the damaged 'rack' is taken to another area Mon/Tues.
I'm reserving my opinions here until I determine more facts. 'Whatever' will be posted here.
Pure opinion on my part as of now is a phase to ground fault at the disco, what was "hot" is unknown.
John


Yup, I found that in the police reports today, they said the EC was from Mass. I can understand why you don't have any Pic's or information to give out, it is still an active investigation.
Posted By: HotLine1 Re: Arc flash accident video - 06/11/07 09:34 PM
MX/LK:
As soon as I hear any further info that's 'public', I'll post it here.

Yes, Mass guy, no info on his condition today; Tues I'm calling their office for an update on the guys condition.
John
Posted By: mxslick Re: Arc flash accident video - 07/04/07 07:27 PM
John:

Any follow-up to this incident that you're allowed to share?

Posted By: HotLine1 Re: Arc flash accident video - 07/05/07 03:21 PM
As of last Thursday (6/28/2007) all that is being 'said' is:
Guy was able to speak at Burn Unit, wife was at his side. 30-40% 2nd & 3rd degree burns on face, neck and upper body areas. No info on anything other than burns.

As to the cause...nothing official available.

Speculation and opinions (unofficial) is that the switch was in the 'ON' position as the fuses where being installed, and 'something' went to ground on the dead front.

The above paragraph is the 'buzz' going around from various unofficial sources, there is NO official comment on this accident.

Stay safe.
John
Posted By: HotLine1 Re: Arc flash accident video - 07/19/07 11:27 AM
As of 7/18/2007 the young man is expected to return to work within the next 30 days. His injuries were not as severe as everyone thought. For one, I'm glad for him; he is one lucky guy.

Hopefully, someone else that was around, or who may have read this, or seen any of the videos will excersize caution.

Details of the cause are still unavailable due to a possible ongoing investigation.

John
© ECN Electrical Forums