ECN Forum
Posted By: GovtVoltage Is this a Feeder? - 09/01/05 05:12 PM
Is the Conductors for a Sub-Panel considered a Feeder and are we subsequently able to use Table 310.15(B)(6) to calculate our wire size?
Posted By: gfretwell Re: Is this a Feeder? - 09/01/05 06:50 PM
You can only use 310.15(B)(6) if this is the feeder to the entire dwelling load, like the feeder from an outside main disconnect to the main panel inside the house. A sub panel off the main is sized with 310.16.
It has to do with load diversity.
Posted By: Tom Re: Is this a Feeder? - 09/01/05 09:59 PM
Table 310.15(B)(6) is one of the areas of the code that can cause a fistfight to break out. While I am in complete agreement with the post from Gfretwell, there are many parts of the country where this is not enforced this way and you would be able to use the table for your feeder. If your work is subject to inspection, it is best (as always) to consult with the AHJ prior to commencing work.

Tom
Posted By: Roger Re: Is this a Feeder? - 09/01/05 10:21 PM
I agree with Greg and Tom, 310.16

Roger
Posted By: GovtVoltage Re: Is this a Feeder? - 09/02/05 12:36 AM
Thanks for the reply guys......
Posted By: iwire Re: Is this a Feeder? - 09/03/05 10:53 AM
And I say do away with Table 310.15(B)(6) to make the NEC smaller and with less sections of confusion. [Linked Image]

Is using 310.16 that outrageously expensive?

Bob
Posted By: winnie Re: Is this a Feeder? - 09/03/05 01:54 PM
Given what copper prices are doing, every little bit helps.

On the other hand, reduced resistance in feeders means more efficient deliver of power to the load, and lower lifetime costs. If you take the 'Copper Development Association' at their word, you'd be upsizing from 310.16 by a size or two anyway. [Linked Image]

On the left foot, I'd rather do away with 310.15, and instead change the calculations for service size to give a _separate_ result for conductor ampacity and required OCPD, in much the same way that oversized OCPD can be used with a given conductor ampacity for specific loads such as motors or welders.

-Jon
© ECN Electrical Forums