ECN Forum
Posted By: Clydesdale 240Volt Loads without neutral - 08/23/05 09:50 PM
How come some 240V single phase loads don't require a neutral; just 2 hot legs and a ground?
Posted By: Sandro Re: 240Volt Loads without neutral - 08/23/05 09:58 PM
Load is Balanced. No neutral req.
Posted By: Clydesdale Re: 240Volt Loads without neutral - 08/23/05 11:40 PM
So in a 240 V oven the load isn't balanced?
Posted By: Attic Rat Re: 240Volt Loads without neutral - 08/24/05 12:18 AM
... Clydesdale,it's not that the load is unbalanced in an electric oven,..but that the timer,clock and light requires 120 volts,..ergo the much needed neutral.. [Linked Image] [Linked Image]
Russ
Posted By: renosteinke Re: 240Volt Loads without neutral - 08/24/05 01:30 AM
Clyde, let me try to give a VERY simple explanation.

You have two "hot" wires. They are "hot" with AC. Measure either to ground, and you have 120 volts; together, and you have 240.

This is because the 120 originates at opposite ends of the same transformer. Since they come from the same transformer, they are exactly opposite in timing of the "60 hz."

In a manner of speaking, the first wire is at +120 at the exact same instant as the other is at -120. So they can be considered to "cancel each other out;" were there a neutral wire, it would have no current flowing on it.
Another way to look at it is that one wire is "hot" while the other is "off." In this model, you imagine each wire using the other as a neutral, in turn.
Posted By: gfretwell Re: 240Volt Loads without neutral - 08/24/05 01:32 AM
I still wonder why the appliance folks didn't just use 240v bulbs, motors and timers in dryers and ranges.
They sell millions every year so there is plenty of volume. These parts are just used in the specific appliance anyway.
There may have been a big cutover but that is nothing compared to the change in a quarter billion dryer and range receptacles and a mixed cord standard.
Posted By: sierra electrician Re: 240Volt Loads without neutral - 08/24/05 02:20 AM
Let me see if I understand this theory correctly. Since I don't have an oven I'll just hold the 2 hot legs together to simulate the element, Timmy are you ready?.........Will they still "cancel each other out" or will see a really huge flash, oh well here it goes.

Ah Oh, I think we need a new Timmy!
Posted By: Clydesdale Re: 240Volt Loads without neutral - 08/24/05 03:39 AM
ok. so, the clock/timer in the 240V appliance is only using one hot leg(120V), therefore my resoning tells me that there is unbalanced current.
Posted By: Larry Fine Re: 240Volt Loads without neutral - 08/25/05 05:52 PM
Correct - the current is unbalanced by an amp or two, which is why this type of appliance (dryer, range, etc.) now requires a neutral.

A dryer, for example, uses 240 only for the heating element, which is why they function fine on 208v with slightly less heating power.
Posted By: foestauf Re: 240Volt Loads without neutral - 08/26/05 11:33 PM
Like said they balance the load between eachother, and there will always be an amp or two differance, just the way the phase works.

Then you get into 3-phase wich has an even less amount of time between pulses. In 240 you only have 2 pulses per cycle, at 3phase you get 3 pulses, so less amount of time that a device's voltage is lowering.
Wich is why 3-phase is more efficient.

Now all new range/dryers require a nuetral, but still not on air handlers, A/C's, water heaters etc...
Posted By: Clydesdale Re: 240Volt Loads without neutral - 08/31/05 09:26 PM
Thanks to everyone for responding. I really appreciate it!
Posted By: Dnkldorf Re: 240Volt Loads without neutral - 08/31/05 09:58 PM
Reno, did you mean +180 degrees apart from each other, not +120?


Dnk....
Posted By: Clydesdale Re: 240Volt Loads without neutral - 09/01/05 01:53 AM
This is also something I was wondering. Is 120VAC cycling +120V to -120V or is it +60 to -60 making the Peak to Peak voltage 120? I realize 240VAC is 2 sine waves offset 180 deg. causing simultaneus voltage positive and negative, but was wondering if the voltage was caluculated Peak to Peak or from the x axis(y=0). Also, the more I try to visualize the electron flow for a single phase 240 VAC load, it seems as though the electrons are flowing one direction and then the other every 30Hz. No? If not then how are they flowing?
Posted By: Clydesdale Re: 240Volt Loads without neutral - 09/01/05 02:24 AM
I must consult the textbook.
Posted By: John Crighton Re: 240Volt Loads without neutral - 09/01/05 05:19 PM
Clydesdale, AC voltage is normally specified as the "RMS" (root-mean-square) value. The explanation for this is a little complex, but it basically means that a 120 volt RMS AC source will provide the same power (wattage) as a 120 volt DC source to the same resistive load.

For sine-wave AC, the peak voltage is the RMS voltage times the square root of 2, or 1.414 times the RMS voltage. A 120 volt "hot" conductor alternates between +170 and -170 volts.
Posted By: Dnkldorf Re: 240Volt Loads without neutral - 09/01/05 05:28 PM
Disregard my last post, I thought Reno was talking about the phases being 120 degrees from each other.

I don't think I caught the 120 being an RMS voltage.

Dnk.....
© ECN Electrical Forums