ECN Forum
Posted By: shortcircuit Interchangeable Breaker ? - 04/08/05 12:40 AM
I installed a older 2-pole 15 amp circuit breaker made by General Switch Company(blue handle)into a 200amp Seimens Panelboard for an air handler and fluncked inspection today...

I was under the assumption that General Switch circuit breakers were listed for use in other manufacturers panels?

The Inspector said the "numbers don't match"...

How can I find the listing for General Switch breakers?

thanx

shortcircuit
Posted By: Dave55 Re: Interchangeable Breaker ? - 04/08/05 01:11 AM
As with most failed inspections, it's usually easier to satisy the inspector. I'd change the breaker.

Dave
Posted By: resqcapt19 Re: Interchangeable Breaker ? - 04/08/05 01:23 AM
If the breaker is "classified" for use in the Seimens panel, the breaker will have a listing of the panels that it can be used in. The UL listing information for classified breakers requires that classified breakers be provided with this listing. Just because it fits, does not mean that you are permitted to use it.
Don



[This message has been edited by resqcapt19 (edited 04-07-2005).]
Posted By: shortcircuit Re: Interchangeable Breaker ? - 04/08/05 01:32 PM
The breaker used...

General Switch Co: 2-pole 15 amp type GA, 40 degrees C CTL...

UL: Listed HACR type, issue LL 7902...

Is there a web site to trace the above info?

shortcircuit
Posted By: HotLine1 Re: Interchangeable Breaker ? - 04/08/05 07:30 PM
I have to agree with Don on all counts.
Also, with what Dave55 said; as an EC, sometimes that's the quickest & most economical solution. The amount of time and effort you may have to expend vs a quick replacement cb??

As an AHJ, yes, Don is 100% correct. Show me the documentation & 'no problem'.

John
Posted By: Redsy Re: Interchangeable Breaker ? - 04/08/05 09:21 PM
Used 2-pole CB = $X.xx
New 2-pole CB = $X.xx
Time spent debating acceptability to AHJ
(X Hrs @ $65.00 / hr) = $XX.xx
Satisfaction of "winning" against AHJ= Priceless!?

[This message has been edited by Redsy (edited 04-08-2005).]
Posted By: iwire Re: Interchangeable Breaker ? - 04/08/05 09:38 PM
ShortC as Don pointed out the info is required to be with the breaker.

T&B lists all the panels right on the side of the breaker.

If General Switch did not lable the breaker they would have had to send the info in the packaging.

The supply house that you bought the breaker at should supply the paper work or take the breaker back.

From the 2004 UL white book
CIRCUIT BREAKERS, MOLDED-CASE,
CLASSIFIED FOR USE IN SPECIFIED
EQUIPMENT (DIXF)

Quote
The referenced publication is a compatibility list which tabulates the company name, catalog number, number of poles and electrical ratings of the Classified circuit breaker, in addition to the company name and catalog number of the applicable UL Listed panelboards, and corresponding UL Listed circuit breakers in place of which the Classified circuit breaker has been investigated.

Quote
One copy
of the compatibility list is provided with each circuit breaker.

Bob
© ECN Electrical Forums