ECN Forum
Posted By: Niko another fire hazard panel - 10/29/10 09:19 PM
My client had a short on a GE 15A OCPD and it didn't trip. Today I tested that circuit breaker with a 30Amp load and it wouldn't trip.
Is GE another fire hazard panel? Have any of you had the same trouble?

http://www.circuitbreakerservice.com/images/THQP120.jpg
Posted By: renosteinke Re: another fire hazard panel - 10/29/10 09:27 PM
There are, believe it or not, different types of 'shorts.' Sometimes there is enough impedance - arcing is a high-impedance type of fault - that a breaker may respond slowly.

As for the 30-amp load, the question is: how long was the load applied? Breakers trip faster the greater the overcurrent condition.

Still, everything in this world shows variations in quality, and wear out / break down with time. Maybe you have a bad breaker - but that's no reason to suspect an entire product line.
Posted By: mikesh Re: another fire hazard panel - 10/29/10 11:04 PM
A 15 amp circuit breaker is tripping on a time curve until around 38 amps where it starts to react in it's instantaneous range.
As a rule of thumb you need 6 to 8 times the rated current to trip any circuit breaker and most fuses in less than 8 cycles (instantaneous trip)
A 15 amp breaker will carry 135% or its rating for around an hour or about 20 amps.
So how long did you apply a %100 overload?

Then there are loose set screws, loose bonding terminals, and other bad connections that can add impedance to the fault path which can create sustained faults in the many minutes range where good connections might trip a breaker faster. Imagine your fault path is the EMT and several set screws are not tightened or worse the pipe separates. 8 ohms is enough resistance to allow a 15 amp breaker to feed a fault as if it was a load and the breaker never trips. Can you start a fire with 1800 watts? Sorry I will stop now as it is becoming a lecture.
Posted By: HotLine1 Re: another fire hazard panel - 10/29/10 11:38 PM
Years back I had heating issues with a batch of GE 'Thin' single pole CBs. They originated in Mexico, and could have been the first batch from a GE plant relocation.

Returning the batch for replacements was no hassle at the then local GE Supply. Replacements were USA origin, at my insistance.

As Mikesh said, other issues could lead to a non, or long trip.

Posted By: Niko Re: another fire hazard panel - 10/29/10 11:57 PM
Quote
As for the 30-amp load, the question is: how long was the load applied? Breakers trip faster the greater the overcurrent condition.


I left it on for about a minute.
Posted By: HotLine1 Re: another fire hazard panel - 10/30/10 12:07 AM
Niko:
IMHO, a minute was not long enough. If you want to spend some time, contact a GE company/factory rep and inquire IF they have any interest in testing or disecting that baby.

If it's a fairly new CB they may have a vested interest in checking it out.

Posted By: Niko Re: another fire hazard panel - 10/30/10 12:16 AM
The place is about 40 years old and so are the breakers.
© ECN Electrical Forums