ECN Forum
Posted By: gfretwell How would you do it - 09/13/07 02:11 AM
My wife has a project in some golf course bathrooms. The electrician she hired is having a problem with a plan that makes her happy. They are putting in a switch by the door on a concrete block wall. This is "tie beam" construction so the top 2 blocks are solid concrete. How do you get down the wall? She thinks EMT is too industrial, Wiremold is tacky.

My thought is to come down from the ceiling with pipe and LB into the core below the tiebeam so they can go with hidden wire and a flush box at eye level.

She says what else can you do.
Posted By: electure Re: How would you do it - 09/13/07 02:51 AM
Greg,
Your plan sounds good, but how are they going to wire the light in without some surface wiring method or another?
Also, doesn't this have to meet ADA height?
Posted By: HotLine1 Re: How would you do it - 09/13/07 03:01 AM
How about a ceiling mounted motion detector? No pipe, drilling & nothing ugly! Also, it's ADA compliant!

Your idea sounds like a 'plan' also.
Posted By: renosteinke Re: How would you do it - 09/13/07 03:06 AM
Time to take a roto-hammer to the wall, dig a trench, run your pipe or MC, and patch. At least, that's how they do it in the "Old" country laugh

If the trench is deep enough, you won't even need to bury a protective plate over it either.
Posted By: trollog Re: How would you do it - 09/13/07 03:25 AM
Furring the wall out a few inches is another option. You lose 2-3 inches of room along one wall but you get protected dead space in the wall to run wires, conceal boxes, etc.
Posted By: gfretwell Re: How would you do it - 09/13/07 05:48 AM
The ceiling is drywall under trusses so that is a free fire zone, the only question is the switch by the door for the light.

Reno, the inspector is not going to be happy if you notch the tiebeam. That is structural.

I also suggested the motion sensor but they want a switch too. This is not California and these folks don't mind spending money to keep the fan going all day long.
I suggested putting a bell box on the back wall (the service is there anyway on the outside) and put the motion sensor there. That could be pretty tight to the ceiling and they could come through the soffit and fish over the block wall to that. Then come out of there to a ceiling fan box. Use that as the J box to pick up the exhaust fan, hold a ceiling light and over to the switch. If they decide to go with a paddle fan with a light kit later they will be good to go.
Posted By: A-Line Re: How would you do it - 09/13/07 03:39 PM
How about using one of these?
http://ecmweb.com/product_depot/electric_wireless_switch_sheds/

http://www.lightningswitch.com/
Posted By: Alan Belson Re: How would you do it - 09/13/07 04:01 PM
A pull switch?
Posted By: mikesh Re: How would you do it - 09/13/07 04:09 PM
I hate retrofit in cinder block or even worse in concrete The most versatile is to cut the top blocks vertically until you get past the bond and down to the hollow part and install emt and steel flexible conduit to get down the blocks to the switch. Use a masonry box and a lot of mortar to fill the cut and set the box. Stuff a bug wad of metal screen in the block that the switch occupies to hold the cement or mortar from falling down the wall. You might want to ask the building inspector or a structural engineer what parts of the bond you should avoid but I am sure it is possible to cut it vertically for the depth of 2 or 3 inches you would need to get the emt through. I have done too many of these and that is what i did with Building inspection approval. The ceiling is surface if there is not void above. If you should decide on BX or any aluminum raceway you need to be sure there are no chloride additives in the cement or you will need to protect the armour with tar heavy tape etc.
Posted By: gfretwell Re: How would you do it - 09/14/07 03:36 AM
Thanks, when I presented the options they are leaning toward just using the motion sensor (no wall switch) and using the override function if they want the fan on all the time.

We also found out this ceiling is stucco over wire, not drywall so poking holes is not as easy as we thought.
Posted By: JValdes Re: How would you do it - 09/14/07 02:19 PM
I'm going to remember that motion detector idea. But the ceiling could be concrete to.
Just tell her she has to live with the emt. Just do a real nice neat job.
Posted By: Obsaleet Re: How would you do it - 09/15/07 12:21 AM
Greg,
Cut in a masonary box and purchase a 6' flexible bit(DiversaBit), dirll up from switch box location. Proceed with M/C cable fished down the wall. The bit should have holes in it to use as a fish. Yes I have done this before. It isn't easy but thats why I charge more and still get the job lol
http://www.mygreenlee.com/Products/...oduct_category=314&adodb_next_page=1


Ob
Posted By: gfretwell Re: How would you do it - 09/15/07 04:15 AM
Ob, I don't think we are drilling through 16" of concrete wink
Posted By: HotLine1 Re: How would you do it - 09/15/07 02:12 PM
16" concrete header vs: DiversaBit masonry....odds on favorite would be the header IMHO
Posted By: gfretwell Re: How would you do it - 09/15/07 03:36 PM
You also have a better than fair chance of hitting one of the 4 #5 rebars in the tie beam.
Posted By: winnie Re: How would you do it - 09/18/07 04:50 AM
I would consider using some sort of low voltage control method (for example the same sort of power limited supply and relay used with some motion sensor systems), combined with suitable 'flat' conductors simply stuck to the wall and painted the same color as the wall.

-Jon
Posted By: gfretwell Re: How would you do it - 09/18/07 04:16 PM
This is done now with no wall switch, just the motion detector. Once they get power in there they might go for something else.
© ECN Electrical Forums