ECN Forum
Posted By: poorboy Wye/delta fire pump motor question - 06/24/07 08:55 AM
Have a 150 HP 480 Volt 3 Phase fire pump fed from a controller with a Wye/delta starter. I am running 6 conductors and ground to the(12 lead) motor. My co worker has already hooked previous ones up and installed all 6 conductors based on the FLA on the motor name tag. Tha would be wire rated for 173 Amps, and I found in 430-22 (I think---not near my code book right now) a reference to using wire rated at 58% of FLA from the controller to the motor. This would allow the use of #2 THHN instead of 2/0 or 3/0 and be easier.

In the run configuration of the starter does it use all 6 leads at a time rather than 3 for start and the other 3 for run...it must if code allows this. Where is a good place to look for an elementary explanation of these starters?

I will be able to ask a technical rep on Monday, but I am curious now...Thanks
Posted By: JValdes Re: Wye/delta fire pump motor question - 06/24/07 04:55 PM
poorboy,
Nema rates a 150 hp motor at 180 amperes at 480 3 phase. (180 amps x 1.75 = 315 amps). Use the FLA that is on your motor nameplate.
The fuses or breaker will be 300 amp. Now figure your wire size for this current. Not the nameplate FLA. Size your overload for the motor nameplate FLA.

The motor uses all six leads for wye and delta, with the wye having leads 4,5,and 6 tied together momentarily. Connect all three contactors as shown on your diagram. "trust me, you may not get it right the first time you try to run it"......lol

Since this is a fire pump it may not be considered continuous duty. That will change your values.
Posted By: poorboy Re: Wye/delta fire pump motor question - 06/25/07 11:28 AM
Thank you for your reply! It's not that I can't get a rep to tell me what to install. but I sure like to understand what I'm doing. Your comment about the 4,5,6 leads tied together momentarily is along the ideas of what i was thinking, and I will continue to investigate. The reason for the reduced size of the 6 wires from controller to motor, then, is that each is only one run of two in a set of parallel runs? I will have one set of 3 wires from service to fire pump equip's line side fully rated for the FLA plus percentage required, and then two sets of wires from controller to motor rated at 58% of whatever value the duty requires giving the starter the ability to momentarily run as a wye config and then run as a delta with parallel runs.
I just hooked up a 20hp Armstrong (Emerson motor) fire pump in a building. It was 200volt Low/400 high . It had 12 leads coming out of the peckerneck on the motor. 1-12. It had two options for the low configuration and two options for the high. You could wire it Y start (low config.) or Delta run (low config.). And the same choice for the high connections. This motor was a direct change out in our existing building. It had two interlocks for emergency gen. power and Normal power. Our building is 120/208 three phase. We wired it in a Y start. I just looked at the wiring diagram on the motor. It will only lets you wire it in one configuration only in low or high with all 12 motor leads. Your motor and controller might be different. Maybe your friend paralelled the conductors from the controller to the motor three phase (6six conductors 480 volts) I have not heard of your scenario before. I think the twelve lead motor gives you different options for different system voltages. Here is a interesting forum below related to your question. I was a little confused by your forum question.

http://www.eng-tips.com/viewthread.cfm?qid=127598&page=60
Ok,
I just got some more information from the posting "12 lead motors". I should have looked at the other posting before posting a reply. So I am learning about the Wye/Delta starter. Our existing system did not have that. But this is very interesting.
Posted By: JValdes Re: Wye/delta fire pump motor question - 06/25/07 03:34 PM
Lets not complicate this issue. Can you get an electrical engineering pocket hand book?
Motor shops always pass them out to their customers. Maybe "Ugly"s" has the diagrams.
All you need to do is see the connections and the legend. Then this becomes very clear.
Wye/delta starting has been around forever. Whether it is 12 lead or 6 lead.

JValdes,
I agree with you. I was just trying to understand his question. Ugly's unfortunately only has 9 lead diagrams, not twelve.
Posted By: poorboy Re: Wye/delta fire pump motor question - 06/25/07 09:11 PM
I have been an electrician for 30 years. Much of the time I have worked on commercial jobs---schools, office bldgs, hospitals---and also have been involved with small sawmills and the like. The latter is the extent of my industrial experience until 3 years ago when my company took on the maintenance of a company which has concrete and asphalt batch plants and large rock crushing operations.

That means that all my career I have seen electric 3 phase motors with 3 wires running to them. What few motors were large enough to need soft start starters were reduced voltage type, meaning they also had 3 wires feeding the "peckerhead".

The company who has the rock crushers has a few big motors with soft starts---all reduced voltage except one which I now know is prob. wye start/delta run (or possibly part winding start??) because it has 6 leads leaving the starter.

For that reason when I was told we were running 6-3/0's to this fire pump when we had just run 3-250 MCM to feed it's controller I asked why it was 6 wires and why so big. It was my first experience ever running more than 3 wires to the motor and thus made me curious.

It is very clear now that this allows the motor to be fed one way for start up (by the 3 contactors in the controller swapping leads around---temporarily re-wiring the peckerhead if you will) and another way for run (by the 3 contactors swapping the 6 wires around to being 3 sets of parallel runs to carry the 180 amps FLA of the 150 HP motor).

We ran 6-#1 Copper THHN's to the motor today, and I have a clear mind about it because I now know that 3 of the "half size" wires (#1) will be adequate to carry the less than FLA start up current while it is "wye", and that parallel runs of #1 will carry the 180 Amp load when it is on "run" and in the delta configuration.

You're never too old to learn in this trade.
Poorboy, I Like your last line of your last reply. I love these forums because you always learn something new on here. I called another old timer about the wye/delta starter today. He worked on one 18 years ago at a commercial ice making factory in New York. He said they were very common before newer technology. I got the whole rundown also between him and here. Great post.
Posted By: winnie Re: Wye/delta fire pump motor question - 06/26/07 01:55 AM
Originally Posted by poorboy
We ran 6-#1 Copper THHN's to the motor today, and I have a clear mind about it because I now know that 3 of the "half size" wires (#1) will be adequate to carry the less than FLA start up current while it is "wye", and that parallel runs of #1 will carry the 180 Amp load when it is on "run" and in the delta configuration.


A small clarification: None of the 6 leads are actually electrically in parallel, meaning connected at both ends to form a single conductor. Instead each lead is connected to a separate coil terminal. In a standard delta connected motor with three leads coming out, each lead is connected to a _pair_ of coil ends (well really sets of coils, each comprising one phase), and each lead carries the vector sum of the current from the two coils. Since the two coils are out of phase, the net current from the pair is 1.732 times the current of either one.

Said differently, you might have 10A flowing though a coil set from phase A to phase B, 10A flowing from phase A to phase C, but 17.32A flowing in the phase A lead to the motor.

But in a wye start/delta run motor, each wire gets directly connected to one coil, and the currents get joined in the contactor. Each conductor has to carry the full current of the respective coil. In the example above, each conductor has to carry the full 10A, not half of 17.32A. This is why you have the factor of 0.58, rather than a factor of 0.5, and also why you can 'parallel' conductors smaller than 1/0 in this case. (1/1.732= 0.577)

-Jon
Posted By: jraef Re: Wye/delta fire pump motor question - 06/26/07 06:00 AM
So in case you didn't get that last posting, YES, you can size the conductors for 58% of the motor nameplate current. All 6 of the conductors going to the motor will be carrying current all of the time. The issue of the contactor shorting 3 of them during the Start sequence is irrelevant; the conductors are sized for the running condition and when in Delta (Run), each of the 6 conductors will carry 58% of the motor current. But don't let the 58% confuse you as to the sum being 116%, it is not. The issue at hand is that the current through each conductor path is the motor current divided by the square-root of 3 (1.732). So if the motor FLA were 100A, the Delta current in each of the 6 conductors would be 100 / 1.732 = 57.736, which is rounded up to say "58%".
Posted By: Tesla Re: Wye/delta fire pump motor question - 06/26/07 06:26 AM
Fusing for Fire Pumps is sky high.

Life Safety equipment is NOT fused to protect the motor.

IIRC my last fire pump was 40 HP and it was fused at 1200 A 480 delta across the line.

Generally fusing is set high enough so that the smoke will come out of the motor.

The conductors don't have to be huge, just the breaker/fuse.
Posted By: gfretwell Re: Wye/delta fire pump motor question - 06/26/07 05:19 PM
A fire pump is designed to suck up a carp from the pond, cook it down to bouillabaisse in a locked rotor condition and send it on down the line when the impeller frees up.
Posted By: JValdes Re: Wye/delta fire pump motor question - 06/26/07 05:39 PM
poorboy, I love those rock quarries. But all the one's I have worked with have many large motors. And yes, soft starts are the consensus choice. Also, some drives (VFD's) on the screens. I worked with Vulcan and Hanson aggregates.
Fortunately the wye/delta set up is mainly on european eqiupment. But we will never see them gone completely. I'm glad to see you learned something with your project. Learning is the key to success. But Jon (Winnie) is correct in the statements she made. Put an amp clamp on the motor when it is fully loaded.

Jon.....Very good description. Thanks
Posted By: poorboy Re: Wye/delta fire pump motor question - 06/27/07 01:08 AM
Originally Posted by gfretwell
A fire pump is designed to suck up a carp from the pond, cook it down to bouillabaisse in a locked rotor condition and send it on down the line when the impeller frees up.


LOL, Greg. And Testa's more serious explanation makes a lot of sense. Put the fire out!!

Thanks to all for the answers, and it's good to be able to run stuff by such a collective mass of experience and knowledge---both from the engineering and tradesman's side of things. Ken
© ECN Electrical Forums