ECN Forum
Posted By: arseegee Phase Inverter/converter question - 10/11/02 11:58 PM
A customer of mine has a custom wood working shop at his house. I wired the shop two years ago and it has a 200A 1ph service.

He is purchasing a new moulding machine and vac system that that requires 3ph. The motors will draw a total of 142A @ 240V/3ph.

Having 3ph power from the poco is inot an option. He is miles from any three phase primaries

I have never converted 1ph to 3ph and was wondering how this conversion effects amperage on the primary. Will the draw be greater on the primary or will the secondary equal the primary.

Any one with any formulas for me?
Posted By: caselec Re: Phase Inverter/converter question - 10/12/02 12:25 AM
It looks like your going to be doing a service change. If the motors draw that much there is no way your 200 amp service is going to be able to supply enough power for the required size rotary phase converter. I'm guessing you will need at least 300 - 350 amps single phase just for this equipment. Do a search on Google for "rotary phase converters" and you should be able to find some sizing info.

Curt
Posted By: scjohn Re: Phase Inverter/converter question - 10/12/02 12:50 AM
Just as caselec suggested, converting single phase to three phase with a converter doesnt relieve the primary at all. The load is pretty much the same.
John

[This message has been edited by scjohn (edited 10-11-2002).]
Posted By: Scott35 Re: Phase Inverter/converter question - 10/12/02 02:19 AM
To add some information here, the complete picture - Power Suplying System and Load Device - will have a fixed KVA level. The load draws "X" amount of KVA and the supply must be able to deliver at least the same "X" KVA level, or the load will not be able to draw the required True Power (Wattage) it needs to develope the required Horsepower and Torque.
Results are a decrease in Rotor speed when the work exceeds the maximum HP which the Motor can develope.
This causes most Induction Motors to stall when they slip too far behind or come within a Syncronous Frequency point.

So much for the boring babble! [Linked Image]

I ran some numbers and here are the results:

<OL TYPE=1>

[*]Using the listed 142 Amp @ 240 VAC 3 Phase figure, this equals 58.96 KVA - 58,958.4 VA to be exact,

[*]58.96 KVA on the Single Phase side relates to 245.83 Amps @ 240 VAC 1 Phase.
</OL>

Just something to consider.

P.S. here's the formulas used:

KVA:

I x E / 1000 [1 ph.] I x E x 1.73 / 1000 [3 ph.]

Amperes:

KVA x 1000 / E [1 ph.] KVA x 1000 / 1.73 x E

Scott S.E.T.
Posted By: arseegee Re: Phase Inverter/converter question - 10/12/02 02:39 AM
Scott35, Thanks. I went to my ugly book to work it out but couldn't figure out how to convert back on the line side of the converter...???? (I think I confused myself there!)

I'll have to get more info from the manufacturer on this machine. The only specs I have got is the 100 amp requirement on the moulder and a 15hp vac system.
Posted By: caselec Re: Phase Inverter/converter question - 10/12/02 02:46 AM
Scott35 - I agree with your math but a phase coverter is not 100% efficient.

Arseegee - try this link http://www.phaseconverter.com/rotary-converter.sizing/
Posted By: arseegee Re: Phase Inverter/converter question - 10/12/02 03:14 AM
Caselec, that's what I was thinking. Thanks for the link too!

To add a note, this machine has 4 motors on it. A 2hp, 7.5hp, 10hp & 15hp. All drive different spindles. Then the dust system has another 15hp motor on it.

Guess it's gonna be a service upgrade. But who could have dreamed of a $35K planer/moulder at someones house.
Posted By: Bjarney Re: Phase Inverter/converter question - 10/12/02 05:26 AM
Online application info at sites like: http://www.gwm4-3phase.com/appguide.htm

Also, don't forget NEC Article 455.
Posted By: scjohn Re: Phase Inverter/converter question - 10/12/02 11:50 AM
Dohh.. didnt do the math. The load isnt "pretty much the same".
Sorry for the hasty inacurate post.
John
Posted By: Trainwire Re: Phase Inverter/converter question - 10/13/02 01:40 AM
Um, that is going to be one whacking great converter. something to suggest would (wood? [Linked Image]) be to replace or spec the motors to be single phase. Then you are looking at "just a service upgrade" rather than also adding a converter. Your probably into rotary converters to get any kind of efficency out of it, great amount of floor space, and noise too. the noise of the converter probably isn't an issue because a 3 spindle moulder can be heard several counties over anyway.

Just a thought.

Trainwire
Posted By: nesparky Re: Phase Inverter/converter question - 10/13/02 03:49 AM
As costly as the phase converter will be, it would most likely be cheaper than replacing the motors and controls on an existing machine. The new service will be close to the same either way you go.
I would suggest a 25% growth factor for this customer in figuring the new service.
As his business grows he wii be adding equipment. Depending on his plans, you might ask him to consider a step-up transformer. I believe a 120/240v 1 phase to 480/277 3 phase is available. Might even be less expensive overall.
Good luck.

[This message has been edited by nesparky (edited 10-12-2002).]
Posted By: arseegee Re: Phase Inverter/converter question - 10/13/02 04:11 AM
Single phase motors are not an option. This unit only comes in 240v 3ph or 480v 3ph.

The shop is only about 1000 sq/ft. When we wired it along with his house, he said he MIGHT have a table saw, a miter saw and an air compressor in it. I said lets put 200 amps on it just in case.

Now he has gotten into doing custom mouldings, like reproductions of 100 year old crown and casings. This was not his bag when the shop was built. Live and learn.
Posted By: electric-ed Re: Phase Inverter/converter question - 10/13/02 05:06 AM
Have you considered a variable frequency drive (VFD)?

Some of the newer VFDs will give a three phase output from a single phase input, and can operate multiple motors.

By the way, there is no such thing as a single phase to three phase "transformer".

Ed

[This message has been edited by electric-ed (edited 10-13-2002).]
Posted By: sparky Re: Phase Inverter/converter question - 10/13/02 09:40 PM
nesparky's got a point arseegee,
would'nt it be more economical to rip out said motors?
myself, i've refered situations like this to motor shops with fair results..... [Linked Image]

ed,
got link?
i'd like to read up on that aspect of a VFD.
Posted By: CanadianSparky Re: Phase Inverter/converter question - 10/14/02 10:32 PM
I thought about this one for awhile...what about using a single pahse motor with a pulley and belt to spin the shaft of an old 3 phase motor therby generating a 3 phase voltage on your leads. HAHA, thers got to be some farmer out there thats already tried this.
Posted By: Bjarney Re: Phase Inverter/converter question - 10/15/02 01:05 AM
An engine-generator set in a noise-controlled enclosure?
© ECN Electrical Forums