For what it's worth, ya got a break in one leg. Probably had a "nick" in the insulation, moisture/water got to the Al conductor. Water, al, soil; mix it all together & bingo.....you wind up with an "open". It's OK with no load, cause the "open" didn't burn far enough apart yet.
I believe in pipe.....but there can be problems there also. Check that depth, direct burial is 24", right.
Personally, I would not "patch" it; if it happened once it can happen again, then you put patches on the patches.
Dig it, pipe it, pull it, & it's done.
100 amp feeder, 100', my shop, damn if it wouldn't be pipe & COPPER.
PS: Ypour profile says "sales" as a profession, I strongly suggest that you call a qualified ELECTRICAL CONTRACTOR. BE SAFE.
John